Cake Menu
Now Available - Scones, Cookies, and Muffins! Please Inquire Directly.
Dark chocolate cupcake with chocolate Italian meringue buttercream
“Bento box” honoring Pulmonary Fibrosis Awareness month with cake and matching cupcakes
FEATURED CUPCAKE FLAVORS
Check back often for new flavors!
Pumpkin Caramel Biscoff
Apple cider caramel
Lemon blueberry
Chocolate w/peppermint buttercream
S’mores
Bananas Foster
Peach cobbler with cinnamon buttercream
Eggnog with butter rum frosting
Chocolate with silky orange buttercream
Chocolate with fresh raspberry buttercream
The “Scooby Snack” - Chocolate cake with a trio peanut butter, chocolate and brown sugar buttercream and a crunchy snack on top
Cake Offerings
Prices will vary based on labor and ingredients. Please inquire directly.
Two-layer, one cake flavor, one buttercream flavor, basic design
Custom fillings, toppers and elaborate designs are an additional charge
4-inch “L’il Johnny Smash Cakes” (serves 2-4 people)
6-inch cakes (serves 6-10 people)
8-inch cakes (serves 12-22 people)
9-inch cakes (serves 15-25 people)
10-inch cakes (serves 25-35 people)
Larger and multi-tier special event and wedding cakes are available for custom orders.
Cake “bento boxes” available for special occasions and gifts. Includes one 4-inch cake and 8 cupcakes decorated to match. Please inquire about pricing.
Cakes and Cupcakes
Cupcakes
Sorry, we can only do orders by the dozen.
Includes one cake flavor, one buttercream flavor, basic design
Mix/match flavor combinations, custom fillings, toppers and elaborate designs are an additional charge
$50 per standard-size dozen, $60 per dozen for premium flavors or elaborate decorations.
A 50% non-refundable deposit is required before work is started on any order. No Exceptions. Deposits go towards shopping for ingredients, packaging, and decorations, so please make sure you can commit to an order before making a deposit.
Most of our products are custom made to order. If you don’t see something on the menu, please contact and we’ll be happy to create what you need.
Please try to give a week’s notice on all orders. Rush orders will require an extra service charge.
Delivery is available for an extra charge to many locations in Massachusetts, Connecticut, southern New Hampshire, and southern Maine.
Cake Options and Add ons
Cake Flavors: Vanilla/Chocolate, Marble, Confetti, Cinnamon Brown Sugar, Apple Cider, Coconut, Lemon, Spice Cake, Pumpkin, Earl Gray Tea, Carrot, Red Velvet, Classic Yellow, Cornbread Cake, Graham Cracker
Premium Fillings: Fruit jams, pineapple, apple cinnamon, cherry almond mousse (made with an entire jar of Luxardo cherries), lemon curd, fresh fruit compote of choice, chocolate ganache, peach cobbler, fresh whipped cream
Buttercream Flavors: Vanilla (can be dyed), Chocolate, Mocha, Almond, Amaretto, Italian Anisette, Cinnamon, Maple, Lavender, Peanut Butter Honey (can be made without honey), Fresh Strawberry (in season), Lemon, Lime, Coconut, Orange, Cream Cheese (can be dyed), Caramel Biscoff, torched Marshmallow, classic Italian meringue buttercream (can be dyed and flavored)
Dog-Friendly “Pupcakes” Available!
Honey Peanut Butter Pupcakes with Cream Cheese Peanut Butter Frosting
$30 per dozen
A Trio of Fall Cupcakes
Old-Fashioned Inspired Cake with Bourbon Vanilla Cake, Cherries in Batter, and Silky Orange Bitters Buttercream
Golden vanilla cupcake with vanilla Italian meringue buttercream
The “Melanie Jane” Amaretto Cake
Bananas Foster cupcake
Lemon blueberry cupcake with a silky lemon Italian meringue buttercream
Custom gluten-free 7UP Soda Cake
Floral Christmas Cupcake Collection
Having trouble deciding what flavors you want? Try my rotating premium cake creations that change as I dream them up!
6-inch cake (serves 6-10 people)
8- or 9-inch cake
10-inch cake
Additional charge for custom designs or decorations
Most flavors can also be made as cupcakes
JOhnny’s Premium cakes
“The Melanie Jane”
DiSaronno amaretto-infused golden cake with cherry almond mousse, almond buttercream, and topped with chocolate ganache and sliced almonds
“The Southern Belle”
Southern peach cobbler with cinnamon brown sugar cake, peach compote and whipped cream filling, cinnamon or maple buttercream
“The Sexy Cake”
Chambord-infused dark chocolate cake with raspberry jam/chocolate mousse layers, choice of raspberry or chocolate buttercream, ganache topping
“Sunday Morning Pancakes”
A take on weekend breakfast! - Cornbread cake with blueberry compote/whipped cream, maple buttercream and bacon crumbles. Perfect for the Thanksgiving table.
“The St. Patty’s”
Guinness-infused chocolate cake with bailey’s mousse, ganache or chocolate buttercream
“The Reese’s”
Chocolate cake with peanut butter mousse, chocolate buttercream or ganache
“The French Guy”
Grand Marnier-infused chocolate cake with orange mousse, chocolate ganache
“Summertime”
Vanilla cake, strawberry mousse, strawberry buttercream (made with fresh, in-season berries)
“The Bahama Mama Cake”
Coconut cake and key lime filling, lime buttercream
“John’s Birthday Cake”
Pumpkin spice cake with caramel biscoff-flavored Italian buttercream, caramel drizzle
“Evie’s Coronation Cake”
A nod to my British family overseas. Earl grey tea cake with lavender buttercream
“The Campfire S’mores Cake”
Graham cracker cake with torched marshmallow mousse and ganache topping, crushed graham crackers
“The Pina Colada Song”
Coconut cake with whipped cream and lemon curd filling, lemon buttercream icing, topped with toasted coconut
“What’s Up, Doc?
Carrot cake, pineapple and whipped cream filling, with cinnamon or regular cream cheese icing
“Peanut Butter Jelly Time!”
Yellow cake, fruit jam filling, crunchy honey peanut butter buttercream
“The Creamsicle”
Orange Cake, Whipped Cream and orange marmalade filling, orange or cream cheese buttercream
Dark Chocolate Cake with Mocha Buttercream and a caramel drizzle
“John’s Birthday Cake”
Pumpkin spice cake with caramel biscoff buttercream and a caramel drizzle
Carrot cake with cream cheese frosting
The “Scooby Snack” cupcake
Chocolate cake with chocolate, peanut butter, and brown sugar buttercreams and a crunchy snack on top
Baby Shower Bento Box